Associations between risk perception and safety

doi:10.1016/S0925-7535(97)00038-6

Safety Science

Volume 24, Issue 3, December 1996, Pages 197-209

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0925-7535(97)00038-6 Get rights and content

Abstract

The relationship between perception of risk and involvement in accidents is receiving increasing attention in the offshore oil industry. A self-completion questionnaire survey was carried out among employees on twelve offshore oil installations in 1994.¹ The number of respondents were 1138. Employee evaluations of the status of safety and contingency measures were affected by physical working conditions, attitudes towards safety and accident prevention work as well as management commitment and involvement in safety promotion. These factors were also related to job stress, perceived risk and risk behaviour. There was a significant positive correlation between perceived risk and risk behaviour, but risk perception was not found to predict risk behaviour. Risk behaviour affected accidents as well as near-misses. The possibility that safety cannot be improved by changing individual risk perception is discussed.

References (21)

T. Rundmo
Risk perception and safety on offshore petroleum platforms — Part I: Perception of risk
Safety Science
(1992)
T. Rundmo
Risk perception and safety on offshore petroleum platforms — Part II: Perceived risk, job stress and accidents
Safety Science
(1992)
T. Rundmo
Occupational accidents and objective risk on North Sea offshore installations
Safety Science
(1994)
T. Rundmo
Perceived risk, safety status and job stress among injured and non-injured employees on offshore petroleum installations
Journal of Safety Research
(1995)
Advisory Committee on the Safety of Nuclear Installations
B. Brehmer
Some notes on psychological research related to risk
B.M. Drottz-Sjöberg et al.
Public reaction to radiation: fear, anxiety, or phobia
Health Physics
(1993)
B. Fischhoff et al.
Acceptable Risk
(1981)
R. Flin et al.
Risk Perception in UK Offshore Workers
R. Flin et al.
Risk Perception in UK Offshore Workers

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (208)

Affective risk perception index as a screening tool for construction workers
2024, Safety Science
Affective risk perception has been receiving attention from occupational safety researchers. This study proposes the Affective Risk Perception Index (ARPI) to serve as a screening tool and provides a guideline to researchers and safety practitioners for the use of the ARPI. 536 construction workers participated in a questionnaire survey. ARPI scores were analysed using the 15th percentile, median and 85th percentile to create four categories of ARPI, namely ‘poor’ (0–20 points), ‘moderate’ (21–41 points), ‘good’ (42–55 points) and ‘excellent’ (56–60 points). Hierarchical multiple regression was used to examine the predictive value of the ARPI for the self-reported risk-taking behaviour of construction workers and compare the four categories of the ARPI in predicting such behaviour. Compared to personal factors (including perceived behavioural control, attitude towards risk-taking behaviour and outcome expectancy), the ARPI made the relatively smaller contribution to explaining the variance of the self-reported risk-taking behaviour of construction workers. Results showed that construction workers who were classified as good or excellent in the ARPI engaged significantly less in risk-taking behaviour than those who had a poor or moderate level of affective risk perception. Furthermore, no statistically significant differences were observed between poor and moderate levels of affective risk perception and between good and excellent levels of affective risk perception in predicting the self-reported risk-taking behaviour of construction workers. Therefore, the cut-off score of the ARPI is 42 and the ARPI serves as a practical screening tool for predicting the risk-taking behaviour of construction workers.
Risk perception or hazard perception? Examining misperceptions of miners’ personal exposures to noise
2023, International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health
While perceptions of risk have been examined in the workplace to understand safety behavior, hazard perception has been overlooked, particularly for chemical, physical, and biological agents.
This study sought to establish the prevalence of one type of mismatch in hazard perception, – noise misperception – among miners, to examine whether different types of noisy environments (e.g., continuous, highly variable, etc.) alter workers' misperception of their noise exposures, and to evaluate whether noise misperception is associated with hearing protection device (HPD) use behavior.
In this cross-sectional study across 10 surface mines in the USA, 135 normal-hearing participants were surveyed on their perceptions of exposure to noise at work and were monitored for three shifts, each with personal noise dosimetry, to examine which workers had a mismatch in perceived versus true noise exposure by 8-hr, time-weighted average, NIOSH exposure limits (TWA_NIOSH). Mixed effects logistic regression and probit Bayesian Kernel Machine Regression (BKMR) models examining on the odds of noise misperception associated with four different noise metrics (kurtosis, crest factor, variability, and number of peaks >135 dB) were used to determine which types of noisy environments may influence noise misperception. The relationship between noise misperception and odds of not wearing HPDs during a work shift was further examined.
Our findings showed that nearly 1 in 3 workers underestimated their exposure to noise when their true exposure was in fact hazardous (TWA_NIOSH $\geq$ 85 dBA) for at least one shift, and 6% misperceived hazardous exposures for all shifts. Work shifts with highly kurtotic noise distributions (>3) had 3.1 (95% CI: 1.1 to 8.4) times significantly higher odds of resulting in misperceived noise; no other noise metric was significantly associated with noise misperception. BKMR modeling provided further evidence that kurtosis dominates this relationship, with an IQR increase in kurtosis significantly associated with 1.68 (95% CI: 1.13 to 2.50) higher odds of noise misperception. Although not statistically significant, misperception of hazardous noise exposure was associated with 3.2 (95% CI: 0.8 to 12.5) times higher odds of not using earplugs during a work shift.
Misperception of noise occurs in the workplace, and likely occurs for other physical, chemical, and biological exposures. This hazard misperception may influence risk perceptions and worker behavior and reduce the effectiveness of behavior-related training. Elimination, substitution, or engineering controls of exposures is the best way to prevent hazard misperceptions and exposure-related diseases.
An analysis of engineering students' risk perception to support process safety learning process
2023, Education for Chemical Engineers
Multidisciplinary teams often undertake engineering projects beyond their original discipline involving different kinds of risks. Risk perception is an inherent and embedded part of the decision-making process, which depends on the personal background and instinctive attitudes or behaviors. Process safety and risk analysis training for engineers, and education for engineering students, provide valuable tools seeking safer workplaces; however, personnel’s risk perception is commonly neglected. This paper analyzes the risk perception and appetite of undergraduate engineering students in Colombia based on a survey strategy and a weighted-approach following a Factor Analysis. The survey considered financial, social, physical, and professional risks, and four main reasons for risk-taking or risk-avoiding actions. The Factor Analysis allows us to classify the students tendency as risk-averse o risk-prone, and propose didactic teaching planning using a modular toolbox for process safety education, based on skills identified for junior engineers in Colombian Oil & Gas Industry. A total of 465 engineering students from 12 Colombian universities completed the survey in 2016. The results suggest that risk perception depends on the location, possible risk training, and accessible information. The obtained factors allow describing the students’ overall risk profiles, which can serve as an input for refining the content and curriculum content of current engineering programs regarding process safety. Improving the training of risk management in the engineering curriculum will benefit upcoming multidisciplinary teams in high-risk industries.
Measuring effects of safety-reminding interventions against risk habituation
2022, Safety Science
Despite advances in automation of construction tasks and related technologies, worksites are still characterized by several labor-intensive works and numerous accidents. Various studies have focused on safety management to prevent accidents by encouraging safety behaviors within the workplace. Most studies focus on accident prevention as a relatively short-term event and do not consider risk habituation caused by familiarity. Thus, quantitative investigations on the effects of risk habituation and interventions are lacking. Because the level of risk habituation is relative and varies within individuals, identifying a practical solution suitable for the workplace will be challenging. This study measures the degree of incautiousness and its impact on risk habituation based on the workers' gait stability and provides effective intervention scenarios to delay risk habituation in the experimental setting. The safety intervention scenarios against risk habituation are designed as 1) installing fixed-repetitive intervention based on obstacle location, and 2) behavior-feedback intervention according to performed incautious behaviors; the effects are compared with trends in the average dynamic time warping (DTW) values of the subjects. The results show that behavior-feedback is more efficient than fixed-repetitive alarms against risk habituation. In addition, identifying the optimal intervention level (i.e., timing and frequency) that decreases or slows incautious behaviors over time is necessary. This study empirically reveals the impacts of risk habituation and provides managerial strategies for delivering interventions against negative familiarity in practice.
Exploring inattentional blindness in failure of safety risk perception: Focusing on safety knowledge in construction industry
2022, Safety Science
Inattentional blindness (IB) is a popular human error associated with selective attention or inattention. It can be depicted as an individual’s failing to notice or recognize a visual object or event due to a lack of active attention in a given situation. Dynamic situations at construction sites often can lead to IB, which can cause failure of safety risk perception (FSRP) on hazards and lead to potential accidents. Few studies have focused on the importance of the IB concept in the construction industry. To overcome this gap, 53 supervisors participated in an experiment to analyze the performance of IB in FSRP and safety knowledge-related factors that affect IB and FSRP to establish practical safety management strategies. The results show that IB accounted for 50% of FSRP, validating the importance of IB. Other factors, such as certified training and frequent exposure to accidents, also had positive impacts on reducing IB. Certification and external training showed positive impacts in the low-experience group but not on the high-experience group. Based on these findings, the IB concept should be considered when addressing construction safety management. Practical safety management strategies to improve IB should be applied differently according to the supervisor’s experience.
Integrating scientific and local knowledge into pollution remediation planning: An iterative conceptual site model framework
2021, Environmental Development
Pollution remediation decisions in developing communities are often made with limited technical data and stakeholder engagement. Local knowledge of contamination is oftentimes neglected, resulting in efforts that fail to align with community objectives. In this work, we propose a new approach for incorporating local knowledge on contamination into remediation efforts, resulting in a community-informed conceptual site model framework for pollution remediation. This framework uses qualitative and quantitative social science methods to develop a holistic view of contamination as defined by the community, pairing social knowledge with existing technical information about a site. An example of the application of this framework is provided from a field study conducted in a mercury-contaminated artisanal and small-scale gold mining community in Andes, Colombia. We conducted qualitative unstructured and semi-structured interviews and surveys to elicit local knowledge on mercury contamination. We combined this stakeholder input with limited scientific published literature on mercury contamination in artisanal mining communities to develop different conceptual site models that vary based on the level and type of stakeholder input. Our findings demonstrate how local knowledge on contamination varies due to contextual factors within the community, revealed through the engagement. This work also demonstrates how the new framework can be utilized by environmental practitioners to define the needs, wants, and priorities of stakeholder groups throughout a remediation project, ensuring maximum participation in solution development.

View all citing articles on Scopus

¹: The study was financed by the Norwegian Petroleum Directorate (NPD). NPD's constant interest and support for my research has been a very important motivation factor in my work with these issues.

View full text

Associations between risk perception and safety

Abstract

Safety Science

Safety Science

Safety Science

Journal of Safety Research

Some notes on psychological research related to risk

Public reaction to radiation: fear, anxiety, or phobia

Health Physics

Acceptable Risk

Risk Perception in UK Offshore Workers

Risk Perception in UK Offshore Workers