Elsevier

Public Health

Volume 114, Issue 2, March 2000, Pages 133-136
Public Health

Articles
Potential of using existing injury information for injury surveillance at the local level in developing countries: experiences from Bangladesh

https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.ph.1900618Get rights and content

Abstract

Although injury is a major public health problem in Bangladesh, as in other low income countries in the world, it has gained very little attention from policy makers, or even health professionals, mainly due to the lack of valid injury information in these countries. To address the injury problem, there is an urgent need to develop injury surveillance activities, based on existing sources of potential interest for obtaining injury information. This study is an evaluation of existing injury data sources in terms of prevention orientation representativeness, and sustainability with respect to the use of these sources in injury surveillance at the local level in Bangladesh. The regular injury information sources that have been used in this study include hospital records, post-mortem reports, newspaper reports, and police reports. In addition, 60 health practitioners in the area, representing various categories, were interviewed according to questionnaire, and ten others were interviewed in-depth about their opinions regarding their participation in the injury surveillance system. The information sources were then assessed for their potential to be included in the surveillance system. The validity was estimated by means of comparisons of the different sources.

All the existing sources of injury information suffer from certain deficiencies such as, lack of representativeness, low prevention orientation and poor sustainability. Post-mortem reports and police reports have been found to be potential sources of mortality data but not morbidity data. Hospital records can be seen as potential sustainable sources of injury morbidity data but suffer from low prevention orientation and representativeness. The injury information was not consistent from source to source and failed to depict the true picture of injury in the area.

To develop an injury surveillance system, a combination of data obtained from several different sources is necessary to compensate for inadequacies in the individual sources and to improve the overall usefulness of the system. Updated with E-codes, hospital discharge records could be used for injury morbidity surveillance, and updated police and post-mortem data can be used for mortality data in injury surveillance systems at the local level in developing countries. Public Health (2000) 114, 133–136

References (23)

  • GS Smith et al.

    Unintentional injuries in developing countries: The epidemiology of the neglected problem

    Epidemiol Rev.

    (1991)
  • Cited by (37)

    • Road safety data collection systems in Iran: A comparison based on relevant organizations

      2020, Chinese Journal of Traumatology - English Edition
      Citation Excerpt :

      Data from police usually are collected in limited resource in this setting and accordingly have a potential for RTIs surveillance.33 While police data source is an important RTIs document, however, it seems that as a registry system it could have limitation and even maybe a source of bias for RTIs reports.31,32,34 In Iran, various organizations and institutions are involved in road traffic injuries as well as its preventing programs, including Police, Forensic Medicine Organization, Ministry of Roads and Urban Development, Ministry of Health and Medical Education, National Terminal Board, and Emergency Medical Services.

    • Exploring data sources for road traffic injury in Cameroon: Collection and completeness of police records, newspaper reports, and a hospital trauma registry

      2017, Surgery (United States)
      Citation Excerpt :

      The hospital-based trauma registry had the most information available of the 3 sources, both in terms of variety and completeness; however, the police and newspaper data sources provided some specific information that was unavailable in the hospital trauma registry. The relative under-reporting of injury events in newspaper and police data sources found in this report echoes findings from other countries, including LMIC contexts.12,14,22,23 In Pakistan, newspapers recorded a greater number of fatalities when compared with police data, but police data had more records of nonfatal RTIs.7

    • Development and piloting of the Fiji Injury Surveillance in Hospitals System (TRIP Project-1)

      2013, Injury
      Citation Excerpt :

      Yet, available data are inadequate to inform a robust national injury prevention strategy based on the causes and nature of injuries, as well as the high-risk groups involved. A systematic approach to monitor and address the burden of injuries in developing nations is long overdue in Pacific Island countries and elsewhere.10–12 In order to obtain a profile of the leading causes of death and hospitalisation due to injury in Fiji, a project specific data collection system – the Fiji Injury Surveillance in Hospitals (FISH) – was established as a component of the Traffic Related Injury in the Pacific (TRIP) project.

    • What is the potential of trauma registry data to be used for road traffic injury surveillance and informing road safety policy?

      2011, Journal of Safety Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      While Australia has the capacity to perform routine injury mortality and hospitalized morbidity surveillance activities, road traffic injury surveillance capabilities across countries vary. In some countries, a great deal of information may be available for surveillance of road traffic injuries, such as the linked crash outcomes data evaluation systems (CODES) in the United States (National Highway Traffic Safety Authority, 1996) used to examine road traffic-related injuries, while in other countries road traffic injury information may be obtained from hospital records, police reports, or newspaper clippings (Rahman, Andersson, & Svanstrom, 2000), which contain only limited information about the traffic incident and how it occurred. One type of data collection that is increasingly being used for injury surveillance purposes are trauma registries (Forst, Hryhorczuk, & Jaros, 1999; Johnson & Moore, 1997; Kobusingye & Lett, 2000; Layde, Stueland, & Nordstrom, 1996; Pollock & McClain, 1989).

    • Advancing Injury Prevention and Trauma Care in North America and Globally

      2007, Surgical Clinics of North America
      Citation Excerpt :

      Sometimes as few as 10% of injury-related events or even injury-related deaths are recorded [9,10]. Despite these problems, several LMICs have reported sustainable improvements in injury surveillance, often by building on existing information systems [10–13]. For example, South Africa's National Non-Natural Mortality Surveillance System is built on data collated from selected mortuaries nationwide.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text