Increases in fines and driver licence withdrawal have effectively reduced immediate deaths from trauma on Brazilian roads: first-year report on the new traffic code
Introduction
Motor vehicle crashes and accidents involving pedestrians and vehicles account for much disability and loss of life in Brazil. Second to gunshot wounds, they are the most common causes of death among our population between 15 and 39 years of age and are the third cause of death between the ages of 10 and 49 years [1], [2]. Several reports from developed countries show that the rates of fatal and non-fatal injuries from motor vehicle crashes have declined over the years, largely associated with compliance to mandatory seat-belt and helmet use [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7]. Compliance to the same laws is a fact in Brazil; but motor vehicle crashes continue to kill, with death rates increasing steadily for years. It has been estimated that 90% of these crashes are caused by human error, while 6% are caused by road defects and 4% by mechanical failures [2].
On 21 January 1998, a new National Traffic Code began to be enforced in Brazil, in an attempt to reduce the number of deaths on the roads. This new code replaces a 33-year-old code and seeks to produce short-term changes in driver behaviour through stricter enforcement and higher penalties. The main changes were a large increase in fines, in some cases ten-fold, and a rigid penalty scoring system that leads to driver licence withdrawal. Speed limits were actually raised on many highways, but adherence to the rules has been more closely and effectively monitored.
Our purpose now is to analyse the impact in its first year of this new traffic code, which has punishment as its most striking feature, on the number of accidents, injured patients and immediate deaths on Brazilian interstate highways. Additionally, emergency room admissions to a level I trauma centre in downtown São Paulo were evaluated to show the impact of the new code on the incidence of injury from accidents occurring within an urban area.
Section snippets
Methods
The incidence of accidents, injured patients and immediate deaths on Brazilian interstate highways between 21 January 1998 and 20 January 1999 was compared with the corresponding data obtained between 21 January 1997 and 20 January 1998. Data were collected and published by the Departamento Nacional de Trânsito, the National Traffic Agency of the Brazilian Government, and made widely available through the lay press. Only eight out of 26 Brazilian states (Tocantins, Acre, Amazonas, Amapá, Goias,
Results
The new Brazilian Traffic Code was associated with a 21.3% reduction in the number of accidents occurring on interstate highways, from 327 640 in 1997 to 257 866 in 1998. More importantly, there was a 24.7% reduction in immediate deaths, saving 5962 lives (Fig. 1). There was also a marked decrease in tickets issued on the highway, which fell from 601 977 to 304 785, a 49.5% reduction.
A similar pattern was observed in downtown São Paulo, where there was a 33.2% reduction in motor vehicle-related
Discussion
Expensive tickets and threatened driver licences have proved to be an effective means of decreasing the first-peak, trauma-related, immediate deaths on Brazilian roads and the emergency room admissions from motor vehicle accidents in an urban area. Although the impact of the new code on the second- and the third-peak mortality could not be estimated, it is likely that morbidity and hospital mortality were reduced.
The social and economic impact of these findings is dramatic. Trauma is an
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by Fundação de Amparo a Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo, grant FAPESP – 98/15658-0.
References (7)
- Anuário Estatı́stico de Mortalidade. Fundação Nacional de Saúde, Ministério de Saúde, Brasil,...
- Fundação Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatı́stica — IBGE, Fundação Sistema Estadual de Análise de Dados...
- et al.
Putting a lid on injury costs: the economic impact of the California motorcycle helmet law
J. Trauma
(1998)
Cited by (39)
Perioperative cardiac arrest and mortality in trauma patients: A systematic review of observational studies
2020, Journal of Clinical AnesthesiaEstimating the impact of the Penalty Point System on road fatalities in Spain
2020, Transport PolicyCitation Excerpt :Similar results have been obtained in other latitudes like, for example, Brazil. Poli de Figueiredo et al. (2001) found that the new Brazilian Traffic Code, that included a rigid PPS, provoked a reduction of 21% and 25% in the number of accidents and deaths, respectively. For Spain, Aparicio-Izquierdo et al. (2011) found that the number of fatalities on the road within 24 h after the accident, the number of excess speed sanctions from radar controls and the number of sanctions for non-use of protective systems (seat belt and helmet) lowered from before to after (until 2009) the PPS came into force.
The effectiveness and influencing factors of a penalty point system in China from the perspective of risky driving behaviors
2019, Accident Analysis and PreventionAssociation between increase in fixed penalties and road safety outcomes: A meta-analysis
2016, Accident Analysis and PreventionCitation Excerpt :Two studies reporting such changes were omitted from the meta-analysis. One of these studies (Poli de Figueiredo et al., 2001) relied on data for only one year before and one year after the change. A subsequent study (Maffei de Andrade et al., 2008) found these years to be atypical of long-term trends.
The costs of avoiding accidents: Selective compliance and the 'Peltzman effect' in Italy
2012, International Review of Law and EconomicsCitation Excerpt :At the same time, some drivers systematically infringe traffic law rules even under a PPS. Several country-based studies provide evidence of positive impacts of a PPS in terms of its ability to increase deterrence (Haque, 1990; Zaal, 1994; Vaa, 2000; Zambon et al., 2008) and improve road safety (Hussain, Nayyar, Brady, Beirne, & Stassen, 2006; Papaioannou, Mintsis, Taxiltaris, & Basbas, 2002; Poli de Figueiredo, Rasslan, Bruscagin, Cruz, & Rocha e Silva, 2001; Zambon et al., 2007). Other empirical analyses show the potential of a PRDL to discriminate between different categories of drivers according to their offense propensity.
Driving licenses based on points systems: Efficient road safety strategy or latest fashion in global transport policy? A worldwide meta-analysis
2012, Transport PolicyCitation Excerpt :In this way almost fifty studies with these characteristics were located although they are all greatly heterogeneous, especially with regard to their methodologies. Some are eminently theoretical (such as Basili and Nicita, 2005 and Bourgeon and Picard, 2007), whilst others are based on a comparison of before-and-after statistics (Poli de Figuereido et al., 2001). Only a sample of suitable studies was selected, using typical inclusion criteria in meta-analysis (see Elvik, 1999), i.e., those which: 1.