Article Text

Download PDFPDF
395 Global guidance for drowning prevention: barriers to implementation in low-resource settings
  1. Tom Mecrow1,
  2. Shayne Baker2,
  3. George Makasare3,
  4. Jessica Leech4,
  5. James Bonney1,
  6. Muhammed Said5,
  7. Joost Bierens6,
  8. Graham Buckley7,
  9. Ash Jones8,
  10. Jill Fortuin-Abrahams9,
  11. Geh Cheow Mei10,
  12. Aminur Rahman11,
  13. Amy Peden12
  1. 1Royal National Lifeboat Institution
  2. 2Royal Life Saving Society Commonwealth
  3. 3Rashtriya Life Saving Society (India)
  4. 4World Health Organisation – Geneva
  5. 5The Panje Project (Tanzania)
  6. 6Koninklijke Nederlandse Reddingsmaatschappi, Netherlands
  7. 7Hue Help - Vietnam
  8. 8Swim England
  9. 9National Sea Rescue Institute - South Africa
  10. 10Life Saving Society Malaysia – Penang
  11. 11Centre for Injury Prevention and Research Bangladesh
  12. 12University of New South Wales, Australia

Abstract

Background The World Health Organization recommend the teaching of basic swimming skills to school aged children, and the training of community members in rescue and resuscitation as key interventions for the prevention of drowning. Recent practical guidance published by the WHO provides a high-level synopsis of the processes, policies and documents required to implement these interventions. However, since a relatively limited numbers of organisations have experience delivering these interventions in LMIC settings, more detailed guidance is required to ensure safe and effective implementation, particularly during scale-up.

Objective To ensure this practical guidance is applicable and useable in LMICs, we convened practitioners from low-resource settings to identify good practice, barriers to implementation, and co-design technical resources to support intervention delivery.

Methods Gap analysis on the WHO Practical Guidance identified topic areas where the guidance referred to practice, policy or documentation, but provided no (or limited) further detail. Seventeen practitioners (representing 13 countries) delivering basic swimming skills, and twenty-two practitioners (representing 14 countries) delivering rescue and resuscitation training in low-resource settings were identified and sent a questionnaire to understand current practice against the topic areas in the WHO guidance.

Two four-day facilitated workshops, one for basic swimming skills and one for rescue and resuscitation, were then held in Tanzania (Sept 2022) and India (Oct 2023). Facilitators worked through a set of pre-defined questions to identify barriers to implementation, gain consensus on good practice, and develop technical resources that would assist organisations implement the practices.

Results This process identified 8 topic areas where further technical guidance was required including safety critical topics (safeguarding and auditing of training sites), and topics likely to impact programme uptake (addressing fears of disease transmission during resuscitation).

Participants highlighted several barriers to implementing the guidance, including a lack of financial and human resources, community scepticism of the interventions, communication challenges in rural areas, and a lack of standardised and peer-reviewed technical resources tailored to the low-resource environment.

Conclusions Resources developed during the workshops include site safety audit checklists, and an informed consent form that includes guidance on medical screening. Future work will test and evaluate their use.

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.