The need to discontinue the use of the term “accident” when referring to unintentional injury events

doi:10.1016/0001-4575(88)90009-7

Accident Analysis & Prevention

Volume 20, Issue 1, February 1988, Pages 1-8

https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-4575(88)90009-7 Get rights and content

Abstract

Inconsistencies in the common usage of the words “accident” and “injury” are examined. The practical difficulties in applying some commonly accepted definitions are illustrated. It is shown how common notions of “accident” are not supported by the facts and are counterproductive to preventive measures. It is argued that the phrase “injury control” provides a more comprehensive perspective of the problem than the phrase “accident prevention”, but its use also has disadvantages. It is concluded that health professionals should discontinue using the term “accident” and associated phrases, when referring to unintentional injury events.

References (53)

D.J. Besharov
Towards better research on child abuse and neglect: Making definitional issues an explicit methodological concern
Child Abuse and Neglect
(1981)
L.H. Day
Death from non-war violence: An international comparison
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1984)
Accident Compensation Corporation
ACC Statistics
(1982)
American Academy of Paediatrics
Reducing the toll of injuries in childhood requires support for a focused research effort
Paediatrics
(1983)
American National Standards Institute
Method of Recording Basic Facts Relating to the Nature and Occurrence of Work Injuries
(1969)
A.G. Arbous et al.
Accident statistics and the concept of accident proneness
Biometrics
(1951)
Auckland Legal Research Foundation
Accident Compensation Seminar
(1974)
B.M. Baker
The excuse of accident
Ethics
(1983)
S.P. Baker
Injury Control
S.P. Baker et al.
The Injury Fact Book
(1984)

C.G. Cayten

Accidental injuries, epidemic of the decade

Penn. Med.

(1983)

Centers for Disease Control and Consumer Product Safety Work Group

Proposed Modification of ICD-10 Injury Codes

(October 1985)

H.F. Davis et al.

The 1990 objectives for the nation for injury prevention: a progress review

Public Health Reports

(1984)

Department of Statistics

Report of the Review Committee on New Zealand Statistics of Accidents Involving Injury

(1984)

T.C. Doege

An injury is no accident

N. Eng. J. Med.

(1978)

D.D. Duckworth

The Classification and Measurement of Disablement

W. Haddon

Advances in the epidemiology of injuries as a basis for public policy

Public Health Reports

(1980)

W. Haddon

Strategy in preventive medicine: Passive vs active approaches to reducing human wastage

J. Trauma

(1974)

W. Haddon

The changing approach to the epidemiology, prevention and amelioration of trauma: The transition to approaches etiologically rather than descriptively based

Am. J. Public Health

(1968)

W. Haddon et al.

Accident Research Methods and Approaches

(1964)

A.R. Hale et al.

A Review of the Industrial Accident Research Literature

(1972)

C. Hassal et al.

Suicides in Birmingham

Br. Med J.

(1972)

P.C. Holinger

Violent deaths among the young: Recent trends in suicide, homicide and accidents

Am. J. Psychiatry

(1979)

R. Honkanen et al.

Construction of the computerized accident registration system in a casulty department

Scand. J. Soc. Med.

(1980)

R.R. Hutcherson et al.

Accidents masking suicide attempts

J. Trauma

(1980)

Cited by (43)

Trauma Demographics and Injury Prevention
2024, Surgical Clinics of North America
Terminology and methods used to differentiate injury intent of hospital burn patients in South Asia: Results from a systematic scoping review
2024, Burns
A key component in the classification of all injury types is to differentiate whether the injury was deliberately inflicted and by whom, commonly known as “intent” in the surveillance literature. These data guide patient care and inform surveillance strategies. South Asia is believed to have the greatest number of intentional burn injuries, but national surveillance data is not disaggregated by injury intent. Scientific literature can be used for injury surveillance where national data collection does not exist. In order to synthesise research findings, it is essential to assess the potential impact of misclassification bias. We therefore conducted a systematic scoping review to understand terminology and methods used to differentiate injury intent of hospital burn patients in South Asia.
We followed the methods in our registered protocol (https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/DCYNQ). Studies met defined population, concept, context, and study design criteria. The databases Embase, MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycInfo, and PakMediNet were searched. Two reviewers independently screened results. Data were extracted in a standardised manner and verified. The rigour of the method used to differentiate injury intent was appraised.
1435 articles were screened. Of these, 89 met our inclusion criteria. Most articles were from India and Pakistan, and used an observational study design. There were 14 stem terms used in the articles. The most common was “cause”. There were 40 classifier terms. The most common were “accident”, “suicide”, and “homicide”. Few articles defined these terms. The method used to differentiate injury intent was only described explicitly in 17% of articles and the rigour of the methods used were low. Where methods of differentiation were described, they appear to be based on patient or family report rather than multidisciplinary assessment.
The heterogeneity in terms, lack of definitions, and limited investigation of injury intent means this variable is likely to be prone to misclassification bias. We strongly recommend that the global burn community unites to develop a common data element, including definitions and methods of assessment, for the concept of burn injury intent to enable more reliable data collection practices and interstudy comparisons.
History of Injury and Violence as public health problems and emergence of the National Center for Injury Prevention and Control at CDC
2012, Journal of Safety Research
Citation Excerpt :
“When the word is used to describe human error, it frequently does so in a way that inhibits examination of the factors contributing to the error and consequent injury …the public usually associates the word with an event, not with the damage that results” (Loimer & Guarnieri, p 101). Efforts to replace the word accident with injury, however, have only been partially successful (Langley, 1988). Some progress was made in the 1930s as psychologists looked for the causes of industrial accidents.
Injuries and violence are among the oldest health problems facing humans. Only within the past 50 years, however, has the problem been addressed with scientific rigor using public health methods. The field of injury control began as early as 1913, but wasn't approached systematically or epidemiologically until the 1940s and 1950s. It accelerated rapidly between 1960 and 1985. Coupled with active federal and state interest in reducing injuries and violence, this period was marked by important medical, scientific, and public health advances. The National Center for Injury Prevention and Control (NCIPC) was an outgrowth of this progress and in 2012 celebrated its 20th anniversary. NCIPC was created in 1992 after a series of government reports identified injury as one of the most important public health problems facing the nation. Congressional action provided the impetus for the creation of NCIPC as the lead federal agency for non-occupational injury and violence prevention. In subsequent years, NCIPC and its partners fostered many advances and built strong capacity. Because of the tragically high burden and cost of injuries and violence in the United States and around the globe, researchers, practitioners, and decision makers will need to redouble prevention efforts in the next 20 years. This article traces the history of injury and violence prevention as a public health priority – including the evolution and current structure of the CDC's National Center for Injury Prevention and Control.
Occupational injury and accident research: A comprehensive review
2012, Safety Science
Citation Excerpt :
Injuries are hardly governed by chance, while an event occurring accidently connotes a chance phenomenon (Wehmeier et al., 2005). There are inconsistencies and overlaps in researchers’ usage of the terms accident and injury, and a number of research articles set to investigate accidents actually analyze injuries (Langley, 1988). A large and diverse literature is available on workplace safety, accident and injury research.
In this paper, a comprehensive review of the concepts of occupational injury and accident causation and prevention is presented. Starting with hazard identification, the issues on risk assessment, accident causation, and intervention strategies are discussed progressively. The distinctiveness and overlaps in accident and injury research are highlighted. Both empirical research in terms of hypotheses tested and theoretical research such as accident causation models are compared and contrasted. Finally, based on the critical appraisal of the comprehensive review, future research directions on occupational injury research are delineated.
Prevention of burn injuries
2012, Total Burn Care: Fourth Edition
Perceptions of injury causes and solutions in a Johannesburg township: Implications for prevention
2000, Social Science and Medicine
As with other diseases, citizen perceptions of injury causes and solutions are important determinants of their response to the problem. This study explores qualitative responses to questions about the causes and solutions for injuries due to violence, transport, and unintentional burns, falls and other causes from 1075 residents in six neighbourhoods of a low-income area in Johannesburg, South Africa. These included council houses, council apartment blocks and informal settlements. Data were analysed using content analytic procedures. Perceived causes of injury varied sharply between neighbourhoods. Violence was seen as an outcome of unemployment, socialisation, drug abuse and drug dealing in the formal housing areas, while in the informal settlements it was attributed to unemployment, poor housing and environmental conditions, and excessive alcohol consumption. In the formal housing areas, suggested solutions for violence emphasised increased policing and other repressive measures that contradicted the attribution of causes to environmental factors. In the informal areas, solutions were more congruent with perceived causes, emphasising housing development, education and employment. Perceived causes and solutions for transport injuries reflected the specific context of each neighbourhood, and indicated strong support for the implementation of environmental modifications to reduce the speed of motor vehicles and thus the number of pedestrian injuries. Where perceived causes and solutions for violence and transport-related injuries were located beyond the community in the broader environment, unintentional injuries due to other causes were seen as more in the sphere of potential personal control, except in the informal areas where electrification and formal housing provision were the most commonly suggested solutions. Popular constructions of the causes and solutions for major categories of injury are important in shaping injury prevention responses, and their careful assessment can increase the likelihood that safety promotion programmes will succeed.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

The need to discontinue the use of the term “accident” when referring to unintentional injury events

Abstract

Child Abuse and Neglect

Soc. Sci. Med.

ACC Statistics

Reducing the toll of injuries in childhood requires support for a focused research effort

Paediatrics

Method of Recording Basic Facts Relating to the Nature and Occurrence of Work Injuries

Accident statistics and the concept of accident proneness

Biometrics

Accident Compensation Seminar

The excuse of accident

Ethics

Injury Control

The Injury Fact Book

Accidental injuries, epidemic of the decade

Penn. Med.

Proposed Modification of ICD-10 Injury Codes

The 1990 objectives for the nation for injury prevention: a progress review

Public Health Reports

Report of the Review Committee on New Zealand Statistics of Accidents Involving Injury

An injury is no accident

N. Eng. J. Med.

The Classification and Measurement of Disablement

Advances in the epidemiology of injuries as a basis for public policy

Public Health Reports

Strategy in preventive medicine: Passive vs active approaches to reducing human wastage

J. Trauma

The changing approach to the epidemiology, prevention and amelioration of trauma: The transition to approaches etiologically rather than descriptively based

Am. J. Public Health

Accident Research Methods and Approaches

A Review of the Industrial Accident Research Literature

Suicides in Birmingham

Br. Med J.

Violent deaths among the young: Recent trends in suicide, homicide and accidents

Am. J. Psychiatry

Construction of the computerized accident registration system in a casulty department

Scand. J. Soc. Med.

Accidents masking suicide attempts

J. Trauma