Incorporating social anxiety into a model of college student problematic drinking
Introduction
Problem drinking among college students represents a major public health concern. Although problematic alcohol use occurs across many age groups, young adults aged 18–24 show the highest rates of alcohol use and have the greatest percentage of problem drinkers Kandel & Logan, 1984, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 1984, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 1997. The majority of college students have consumed alcohol in the past year (over 80% throughout the 1990s; Johnston, O'Malley, & Bachman, 2000), with at least 40% reporting a recent heavy or binge drinking episode (5+ standard drinks for men, 4+ for women in one sitting) in national studies O'Malley & Johnston, 2002, Wechsler et al., 1994, Wechsler et al., 1998, Wechsler et al., 2000.
The pattern of college drinking is unique because it seems to be relatively variable and has a transitory course with only a subset of students exhibiting heavy drinking patterns into adulthood (Weingardt et al., 1998). Although many students “mature out” of heavy drinking (Zucker, 1987), some do not (e.g., Marlatt et al., 1993, Weingardt et al., 1998). Moreover, heavy drinking puts these students at risk for experiencing significant, negative alcohol-related consequences during their college years. Since the mid-1990s, there has been greater media attention given to alcohol-related deaths among college students, including deaths by acute alcohol poisoning, falls, drownings, automobile collisions, fires, and hypothermia resulting from exposure (Wechsler et al., 2000). However, there is a multitude of other less severe negative consequences more commonly experienced by heavy drinkers that may be neglected by the media (e.g., unplanned sexual activity, hangovers, academic problems, legal problems, and lowered immunity; Engs & Aldo-Benson, 1995, Wechsler et al., 1994).
Unfortunately, problem drinkers are not the only individuals who are affected by their drinking behavior. Heavy drinking also endangers other drinking or nondrinking college students and the community in general. In addition to the experience of “secondhand effects” of binge drinking on others (e.g., being insulted or humiliated, experiencing unwanted sexual advances, and having interrupted sleep; Wechsler, 1996), there is an increase in physical or sexual assault or damaging property committed by students when intoxicated Hingston et al., 2002, Wechsler et al., 1994. Approximately 32% of college drinkers report driving under the influence of alcohol (Wechsler et al., 1994), putting themselves and others at risk for injury and death.
Previous research has often utilized self-report measures assessing the quantity and/or frequency of drinking behavior. Many have asserted that using quantity and frequency measures of alcohol use is not sufficient to determine the problem status of college student drinkers. For instance, some heavy drinkers may report low levels of alcohol-related problems, while some light or moderate drinkers may experience high levels of alcohol-related problems (White & Labouvie, 1989). As much of the concern with college student drinking deals with the negative alcohol-related consequences, this seems to be a relevant definition. Thus, the current study examined both weekly alcohol consumption and alcohol-related problems.
Social anxiety may be an important motivator for drinking in college students (e.g., Burke & Stephens, 1999). Recent work has found social anxiety disorder to be the third most common psychiatric disorder, with a lifetime prevalence of 13.3% (Kessler et al., 1994). Alcohol problems and social anxiety appear to be related, as many studies have found higher prevalence rates of alcoholism within samples of socially anxious individuals compared with the prevalence for the general population Davidson et al., 1993, Kushner et al., 2000, Kushner et al., 1990, Merikangas & Angst, 1995 and higher rates of socially anxious individuals in alcoholic samples compared with normal control and community samples Chambless et al., 1987, Merikangas & Angst, 1995, Schneider et al., 2001. Furthermore, the onset of social anxiety disorder typically precedes the onset of alcohol problems Davidson et al., 1993, Kushner et al., 1990, indicating that social anxiety disorder may be a risk factor for alcohol problems. This may be particularly relevant to college students, as there are high social demands and frequent promotion of drinking on college campuses Johnson et al., 1982, Nathan, 1994. In fact, Lewis and O'Neill (2000) found that college students identified as problem drinkers reported higher social anxiety than non-problem-drinkers did, providing evidence of a high co-occurrence of social anxiety and alcohol-related problems in a college population.
Despite this connection, there has been little attempt made to develop a model of social anxiety and alcohol use in the college student population (Burke & Stephens, 1999). Martin and Hoffman (1993) recommend that future research should focus on developing comprehensive models of drinking behaviors that predict relationships among person and socioenvironmental variables using approaches such as path analysis. The creation of such a model, including social anxiety and other correlates of drinking behavior, is essential to improve both the efficacy of prevention as well as treatment efforts.
The expectancy theory Goldman et al., 1987, Goldman et al., 1999 may help explain how social anxiety could be a risk factor for alcohol problems. “Alcohol expectancies” refer to the beliefs that people hold about the effects of consuming alcohol that are believed to influence drinking behavior. Several studies have supported the relationship between expectancies and increased problematic drinking behavior (e.g., Reis & Riley, 2000, Smith et al., 1995). Previous literature has generally demonstrated positive correlations among social anxiety and social and tension reduction alcohol expectancies Burke & Stephens, 1999, Ham et al., 2002, O'Hare, 1990.
Bruch et al. (1992) and Bruch, Rivet, Heimberg, and Levin (1997) contended that shy individuals may fear and avoid drinking if they hold the expectancy that alcohol will increase social assertiveness because they fear that social assertiveness would result in negative evaluation for disinhibited behavior. The study of Bruch et al. revealed that social assertiveness alcohol expectancies acted as a “suppressor variable” between shyness and alcohol use. Although shyness and social anxiety are not synonymous, it is possible that the results of the studies of Bruch et al. could partially be explained by a failure to assess the valuations of the expectancies, a criticism of many widely used measures of alcohol expectancies Fromme et al., 1993, Leigh, 1989.
According to classic expectancy-value theory (Bandura, 1977), an outcome expectancy will only increase behavior if the person desires or values the expected outcome. For example, there is evidence that heavier drinkers may view negative effects of alcohol as more benign than lighter drinkers do (Williams & Ricciardelli, 1996). Furthermore, Leigh (1989) reported that the desirability of alcohol effects, independent of expectancies, added significantly to the prediction of drinking frequency and quantity. Thus, socially anxious individuals that positively value a particular expectancy (e.g., social assertiveness) would be more likely to engage in problem drinking than one who negatively values the expected outcome. It would be expected that this effect would be greater for those with greater levels of social anxiety, as those with more severe levels of social anxiety would have greater motivation to use alcohol to reduce the social discomfort (e.g., Tran, Haaga, & Chambless, 1997).
Gender, living environment, peer influence, and involvement in religion are variables relevant to college student drinking that were important to consider in the model. Although there have been a number of other factors associated with problem drinking, such as genetic influences, often examined in alcohol-related research, the current model focuses on psychosocial, nongenetic variables that are important specifically for college drinking.
Overall, male students tend to drink alcohol more frequently and in larger quantities than female students do (e.g., Clements, 1999, Read et al., 2002). Additionally, male students are more likely to engage in binge drinking Wechsler et al., 1994, Wechsler et al., 1995, meet criteria for an alcohol use disorder (Clements, 1999), and experience more alcohol-related consequences (Read et al., 2002) than women do.
Students living in on-campus residences, such as fraternities, sororities, or residence halls, tend to drink more, more often engage in binge drinking, and report more alcohol-related negative consequences than do those living with their parents (e.g., Harford et al., 2002, Martin & Hoffman, 1993), possibly due to peers who encourage drinking as normative behavior. This may be particularly applicable for socially anxious college students, being faced with many new social situations and having the desire to be accepted socially by their peers. Social desirability, combined with more potential social situations (e.g., interactions with roommates and other students in dormitories) and greater availability of alcohol than those living off campus, may lead to even more alcohol consumption for those with higher social anxiety.
The influence of peers' attitudes and behaviors about alcohol seems to be related to alcohol consumption Oetting & Beauvais, 1987, Reis & Riley, 2000. An atmosphere in which heavy drinking is encouraged and perceived as normative and positive tends to have more heavy drinkers than peer groups in which heavy drinking is not encouraged (e.g., Agnostinelli et al., 1995, Baer & Carey, 1993). The influence of perceived peer drinking norms would appear to be particularly important in the case of socially anxious individuals, as these individuals may have an increased desire to be socially accepted.
Religiosity has generally been found to be negatively related to alcohol use and alcohol problems (e.g., Forthun et al., 1999, Wechsler et al., 1995), independent of the negative relationship between religiosity and sensation seeking (Forthun et al., 1999).
In conclusion, the development of a comprehensive model of the role of social anxiety in college student problematic drinking is essential to understanding the interrelatedness among social and environmental variables associated with problematic drinking behavior in this population. This model would also aid in examining the inconsistencies in the literature regarding the alcohol–social anxiety relationship by including expectancies and valuations of drinking outcomes. Additionally, the model will study an important area, namely, that of social anxiety and problematic college drinking, which has been neglected. Social anxiety and drinking is particularly important in college populations, as college students are faced with a variety of novel social situations as well as situations that involve alcohol consumption. Such a model would serve as the basis for future research, further our understanding of the relationship between alcohol and social anxiety, and inform interventions for problematic drinking among college students.
The following hypotheses involve the path analytic model depicted in Fig. 1.
- 1.
It was hypothesized that expectancies, valuations, and perceived drinking norms would have positive, direct effects on alcohol use and alcohol-related problems. Gender, living environment, and religious involvement were expected to have negative, direct effects on alcohol use and alcohol-related problems, in that being male, living on campus, and lower religious involvement would be related to greater alcohol consumption and problems.
- 2.
It was expected that valuations would moderate the effect of social anxiety on alcohol use and alcohol-related problems, such that those having high social anxiety and high valuations would have even greater levels of the drinking variables than those with lower social anxiety do. Furthermore, it was hypothesized that living environment and perceived drinking norms would moderate the effect of social anxiety on alcohol use and drinking-related problems, such that those with high social anxiety and living on campus or with high perceived drinking norms would have even greater levels of the drinking variables than those with lower social anxiety would.
- 3.
As demonstrated in Fig. 1, it was hypothesized that social anxiety would have positive, indirect effect on alcohol use and alcohol-related problems through the mediating variables of expectancies, valuations, and perceived drinking norms.
Given previous literature indicating important gender differences in drinking behaviors (e.g., Wechsler et al., 1995), exploratory multiple regression analyses were first conducted to examine whether gender moderated the effects of model variables on drinking behavior and drinking-related problems.
Section snippets
Participants
Three hundred forty-three college students who attended the group Alcohol Skills Training Program (ASTP; Fromme, Marlatt, Baer, & Kivlahan, 1994) and agreed to allow their clinical data to be used for research purposes participated in this study. None of the potential participants declined to have their data included. Of the original 343 students, 27 were omitted from analyses, as they were found to be univariate statistical outliers using a standard outlier analysis procedure (Hoaglin,
Distribution normality
As the skew for weekly consumption, perceived norms, and the RAPI exceeded the skew tolerances (a priori as skew >±0.7), transformations adjusting for values less than one were applied to these three variables until a tolerable skew was reached. A square root transformation was applied to weekly consumption and perceived norms variables, and a logarithmic transformation was applied to the RAPI for the remaining analyses (see Meadows & Stradling, 1996, Osborne, 2002).
Correlations and gender analyses
Correlations were conducted
Discussion
The goal of the current study was to develop a comprehensive model of problematic college drinking incorporating social anxiety. Because both social anxiety and problem drinking among college students are significant public health problems, and the study of the relations among these variables have been neglected, the current study was an important step forward in explicating these relationships. The study examined a sample of students referred to the ASTP due to a campus alcohol violation.
The
Acknowledgements
This paper was based on the first author's dissertation.
This study was supported, in part, by a National Research Service Award Predoctoral Fellowship (1 F31 AA13462-01A1) from the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism awarded to the first author.
The authors would like to thank Drs. Marcela Raffaeli, David DiLillo, and Les Whitbeck for providing valuable recommendations and comments about the dissertation. Thanks are also due to Brenda Lindsay, graduate students therapists, and
References (78)
- et al.
Shyness, alcohol expectancies, and alcohol use: Discovery of a suppressor effect
Journal of Research in Personality
(1992) - et al.
Shyness, alcohol expectancies, and drinking behavior: Replication and extension of a suppressor effect
Personality and Individual Differences
(1997) - et al.
Social anxiety and drinking in college students: A social cognitive theory analysis
Clinical Psychology Review
(1999) - et al.
Anxiety disorders and alcoholism: A study with inpatient alcoholics
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
(1987) - et al.
The Alcohol Skills Training Program: A group intervention for young adult drinkers
Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment
(1994) - et al.
The relationship between anxiety disorders and alcohol use disorders: A review of major perspectives and findings
Clinical Psychology Review
(2000) - et al.
Alcohol expectancies and social deficits relating to problem drinking among college students
Addictive Behaviors
(2000) Alcohol expectancies and social anxiety in male and female undergraduates
Addictive Behaviors
(1990)Social anxiety, daily moods, and alcohol use over time among heavy social drinking men
Addictive Behaviors
(1982)- Addictive Behaviors Research Center (1997). The Alcohol Skills Training Program facilitators manual. Unpublished...
Effects of normative feedback on consumption among heavy drinking college students
Journal of Drug Education
Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions
Biases in the perceptions of the consequences of alcohol use among college students
Journal of Studies on Alcohol
Social learning theory
The moderator–mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Handbook for communication and problem-solving skills training
Structural relations among dimensions of the DSM-IV anxiety and mood disorders and dimensions of negative affect, positive affect, and autonomic arousal
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
Prevalence of alcohol-use disorders and alcohol-related problems in a college student sample
Journal of American College Health
Expectancy challenge and drinking reduction: Experimental evidence for a mediational process
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
The epidemiology of social phobia: Findings from the Duke Epidemiological Catchment Area Study
Psychological Medicine
Social anxiety and alcohol use: evaluation of the moderating and mediating effects of alcohol expectancies
Journal of Anxiety Disorders
The association of alcohol consumption with self-reported illness in university students
Psychological Reports
The drinking patterns and problems of a national sample of college students, 1994
Journal of Alcohol and Drug Education
Religiosity, sensation seeking, and alcohol/drug use in denominational and gender contexts
Journal of Drug Issues
Comprehensive effects of alcohol: Development and psychometric assessment of a new expectancy questionnaire
Psychological Assessment
Expectancy theory: Thinking about drinking
Alcohol expectancy theory: The application of cognitive neuroscience
Explaining alcohol consumption and related experiences among fraternity and sorority members
Journal of College Student Development
Alcohol expectancies and drinking behavior in adults with social anxiety disorder and dysthymia
Cognitive Therapy and Research
The impact of current residence and high school drinking on alcohol problems among college students
Journal of Studies on Alcohol
Magnitude of alcohol-related mortality and morbidity among U.S. college students ages 18–24
Journal of Studies on Alcohol
Understanding robust and exploratory data analysis
Social phobia and social anxiety
How to succeed in college
National survey results on drug use from the Monitoring the Future Study, 1975–1999, Vol. 2, NIH Publication No. 00-4803
Drug and drinking behavior among youth
Annual Review of Sociology
Patterns of drug use from adolescence to young adulthood: Periods of risk for initiation, continued use, and discontinuation
American Journal of Public Health
Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R psychiatric disorders in the United States
Archives of General Psychiatry
Cited by (90)
The role of underutilization of protective behavioral strategies in the relation of social anxiety with risky drinking
2020, Addictive BehaviorsCitation Excerpt :Undergraduate alcohol use remains problematic with over 30% of undergraduates endorsing heavy drinking (i.e., >5 consecutive drinks) and 12% endorsing extreme heavy episode drinking (i.e., >10 consecutive drinks; Schulenberg et al., 2017). The undergraduate drinking environment may further exacerbate risky drinking among socially anxious drinkers (Ham & Hope, 2005), for example via drinking to cope with anxiety from meeting new people or participating in novel social situations (Ham, Zamboanga, Bacon, & Garcia, 2009). This observation is concerning because social anxiety disorder more than quadruples the risk of developing an alcohol use disorder (Buckner et al., 2008; Kushner, Abrams, & Borchardt, 2000) and social anxiety symptoms generally onset before alcohol use disorder symptoms (Buckner, Timpano, Zvolensky, Sachs-Ericsson, & Schmidt, 2008), making the college years an important intervention period for at-risk socially anxious drinkers.
Evaluations of alcohol consequences moderate social anxiety risk for problematic drinking
2017, Addictive BehaviorsCitation Excerpt :Drinking is normative and present in many of these social settings (e.g., parties), and thus, may prove to be especially risky for those high on SA. Undergraduates high on SA indeed report drinking to reduce anxiety (Ham & Hope, 2005) and do so in distressing university contexts (Adlaf, Demers, & Glicksman, 2005). However, cognitive theories (Clark & Wells, 1995) suggest high SA individuals should be sensitive to the negative effects of alcohol intoxication (e.g., embarrassing oneself, risk of unplanned sex), and be deterred from drinking.
Social anxiety and alcohol-related impairment: The mediational impact of solitary drinking
2016, Addictive BehaviorsImpulsivity increases risk for coping-motivated drinking in undergraduates with elevated social anxiety
2016, Personality and Individual Differences
- 1
As of August 2004, the corresponding author's affiliation will be: Florida International University, Department of Psychology, University Park, Miami, FL 33199.