Article Text

PDF

Eats, Shoots & Leaves
  1. Barry Pless
  1. Editor; barry.plessmcgill.ca

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    Edited by Lynne Truss. (Pp 209; hardback.) Gotham Books (Penguin Group) New York, 2003, ISBN 1-592-40087-6.

    Most writers punctuate. Not everyone punctuates correctly. Few punctuate well.

    Lynne Truss’s best-seller, Eats, Shoots & Leaves is certain to raise each reader’s writing one large notch. As a bonus, it is a great read; witty, caustic, and wise. If only I had written this review before the book’s meteoric climb to the top best-seller lists (where it remains). Had I done so this would not now be in the company of the hundreds of other reviews, mostly positive, ranging from warm praise to exuberance. Only a few—notably that by Louis Menand in the New Yorker (June 28, 2004, pp 102–4)—are profoundly critical. (Methinks Menand must be a sourpuss.)

    This is a book to be read for fun and profit. If all contributors to this and other journals read it and took it to heart, how much more readable and enjoyable even the most arid scientific papers would be! I read Eats, Shoots & Leaves as a writer who is constantly struggling to improve his style and as an editor who is compelled to improve that of his contributors. (And, as I wrote that, I asked myself “Should there be a comma before the ‘and’”?)

    This book is a cri de coeur of a “writer and journalist who started out as a literary editor with a blue pencil, and then got sidetracked”. Truss is a self admitted stickler. She hectors and mocks but does so with such a relatively light touch that even the most careless writer is unlikely to be offended. Her mission is, nevertheless, a serious one: she is determined to improve writing by focusing attention on the most neglected element in the holy trinity of style—punctuation (the others are structure and words).

    How can you not chuckle when someone stakes out her position as follows: “In some matters of punctuation there are simple rights and wrongs; in others, one must apply a good ear to good sense… Eats, Shoots & Leaves is not a book about grammar. I’m not a grammarian. To me a subordinate clause will forever be… one of Santa’s little helpers. A degree in English language is not a prerequisite for caring about where a bracket is preferred to a dash, or, needs to be replaced by a semicolon. If I did not believe that everyone is capable of understanding where an apostrophe goes, I would not be writing this book.”

    In the Introduction punctuation is defined and described in various ways. One is by using the analogy of stitching: “punctuation as the basting that holds the fabric of language in shape”. Another writer tells us that punctuation marks are “the traffic signals of language: they tell us to slow down, notice this, take a detour, and stop”. Or, “Punctuation herds words together, keeps others apart. Punctuation directs you how to read, in the way musical notation directs a musician how to play.” Quoting a newspaper style guide, punctuation is “a courtesy designed to help readers to understand the story without stumbling’”. (Tricky punctuation that…a quote within a quote!)

    The book has seven sections: An Introduction—The Seventh Sense; The Tractable Apostrophe; That’ll do, Comma; Airs and Graces (the colon and semicolon);

    Cutting a Dash; A Little Used Punctuation Mark (the hyphen); and Merely Conventional Signs (a sort of wrap-up). There is also a bibliography, but no index.

    Alongside the fun, prods, and instruction, Truss has another treat in store for readers addicted to punctuation; segues on the history of various punctuation marks and indeed, on the history of books on the topic. Only one word of caution: it helps greatly if you know something about words and phrases familiar to English-speakers who live in Britain—such as Truss’s favorite candy “Opal Fruits” (one of my favorites, too).

    Frank McCourt (author of Angela’s Ashes) writes in the Introduction, “… pause a moment, dear reader, and imagine this page of deathless prose, the one you’re reading, without punctuation”. If you cannot imagine it, rush out and buy a copy before the stock disappears from the shelves of your favorite bookstore. You will be amply rewarded.

    View Abstract

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.